Federal judges question government arguments in Humana Medicare Advantage lawsuit
Federal appeals court judges challenged Health and Human Services Department arguments during a hearing on Humana lawsuit over Medicare Advantage auditing rules.
FTMQ Health, written by our newsroom0 views

STAT News reported that federal appeals court judges questioned Health and Human Services Department arguments on Monday during a hearing over Medicare Advantage auditing rules. The hearing involved a lawsuit brought against the government by insurer Humana. [1][3]
According to STAT News, Humana is the second largest Medicare Advantage insurer in the United States. In its 2023 lawsuit, Humana v. Kennedy, the insurer challenged the final rule created by the Health and Human Services Department for auditing Medicare Advantage plans. In a separate report, lhindependent.com reported that CHRISTUS Health Plan plans to withdraw from Medicare Advantage. [1][2][3]
Medicare Advantage is a private health plan option that wraps around traditional Medicare to help fill coverage gaps. Originally permitted under the Social Security Act of 1965, the program was expanded under the Medicare+Choice framework in 1997 and restructured by the 2003 Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act. By March 2025, enrollment reached 34.1 million beneficiaries, representing 54 percent of eligible Medicare beneficiaries. [4][6]
The Medicare Advantage program emphasizes coordinated care models, including health maintenance organizations and preferred provider organizations. These private plans frequently use network restrictions and prior authorizations to manage healthcare utilization across the system. [4][6]
In short
- Federal appeals court judges pushed back against government arguments in a hearing on Humana lawsuit over Medicare Advantage auditing rules.
- Humana filed its lawsuit, Humana v. Kennedy, against the Health and Human Services Department in 2023.
- Humana is the second largest Medicare Advantage insurer in the United States.
- Medicare Advantage enrollment reached 34.1 million beneficiaries as of March 2025.
Sources
Every paragraph above points to the numbered items it rests on. Read the originals here.
- [1]STAT+: Judges skewer HHS arguments in hearing over Medicare Advantage audits lawsuitSTAT News, 46d ago (the report this story comes from)
- [2]CHRISTUS Health Plan to withdraw from Medicare Advantagelhindependent.com, 47d ago
- [3]Judges skewer HHS arguments in hearing over Medicare Advantage audits lawsuitSTAT, 46d ago
Background
- [4]Medicare Advantage on Wikipedia
- [5]List of Internet phenomena on Wikipedia
- [6]Medicare Advantage on Grokipedia
Our newsroom writes these reports with the help of software, from the 6 sources listed and nothing else, and checks them against those sources. Facts can still be wrong or move on; the originals are the record. Spotted a mistake? Write to daniel@monsterkong.com.
Related from FTMQ Health
Earlier reports of ours on the same people and subjects.
- United States healthcare stocks drop following proposed federal Medicare audit rulesHealth Care, 2d ago
- United States updates federal health data privacy regulations for patient recordsTop Stories, 3d ago
- Alignment Healthcare sues federal regulators over 2027 Medicare Advantage ratingsHealth Care, 39d ago
- Trump administration proposes Medicare Advantage audits to save 90 billion dollarsTop Stories, 4d ago
- UnitedHealth audit reviews policy creation process but omits coverage denialsHealth Care, 8d ago
More in Top Stories
- United Therapeutics performs first UThymoKidney transplant in EXTEND trial15h ago
- Princeton neuroscience researcher detained by ICE following conference15h ago
- FDA rejects Capricor Therapeutics Duchenne muscular dystrophy cell therapy15h ago
- Northern Ireland ambulance service misses two-hour target over 2,000 times1d ago
- Senior surgeon calls for police investigation into Scottish hospital patient deaths1d ago
- Malaria antibody prevents infection in infants but interferes with vaccine1d ago
Get the day in one email
Reports like this one, the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning. Free, one email a day; readers can comment under every report.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.

Comments
Loading
Join the conversation
Comments are open to readers of our daily email: the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning, free. Sign up and the comment box opens.
Already on the list? Enter the same address and we will send a sign-in link.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.